by Guest » Mon Nov 02, 2009 1:00 pm
[QUOTE=Lazarus;33535]Maybe I misunderstood some of the comments above. However, if self-esteem is a function of accomplishments, than that is illusory self-esteem.
There are definitions of self-esteem and tests on how much you have all over the web, so I won't discuss that. But a person with high self-esteem should still have high self-esteem even when he loses his accomplishments. Because he knows he has it in him to take action.
Take action towards a goal. That will do much more for your self-esteem than the goal itself.[/QUOTE]
Really, self esteem can be broken into two components: dimensional ("I believe I am a good at pick up, and feel proud of that in particular") OR global ("I believe that I'm awesome, and feel proud of that").
The goal is to take those dimensional components of esteem and leverage them to create global esteem, assuming of course you lack that dimensional component to begin with.
Many of the things we do can provide us with self esteem, what you refer to as illusory self esteem. I have this or have done that, therefore I'm awesome and feel good about myself. But, my contention is that with enough illusory self esteem, via accomplishments (again defined by the person), I think one can bridge the gap between dimensional self esteem to global self esteem.
The thinking would be something like this: "I've done xyz so I know I'm capable and thus feel good about myself and how I have become." The point is to disconnect yourself from the accomplishment. You're not happy or have esteem because of what the accomplishment provides, but because you achieved said accomplishment. If it remains, then great, if not you know that are capable of moving forward. You realize that the absence of said accomplishment does not make you a failure. The chances are that you can get it back, or something close, and that's where the esteem comes from.
If you don't have global self esteem right now, the only thing you can really do to improve your esteem and how you view yourself is to accomplish. Global esteem would be nice to begin with, but if you don't have it you can create dimensional esteem which, over time, if followed by other instances of creating more dimensional esteem should provide one with some level of global esteem.
My point is that you can absolutely create esteem, how much depends on the person.