Ok, so you've got all these "extra" girls in your life right now and we've ALL been through dry spells where we can't get the time of day from women.
But seriously, two girlfriends is all a guy can have time for. Three girls is too much. Think about it. If you see each girl 2 nights per week, there's no time for you. There's no time for sarging. There's no time for anything.
As a sort of insurance plan, when you decide you don't want to see a girl any more, this is what you do.
You put her on the back burner such that if and when you decide you want to fuck her again, you can. Because we all know there's likely to come a time again, at some point in the future, where we're in a rut and can't get laid.
How?
Set a date with her. One hour beforehand, call her up. Make sure you have this torn, emotional tone to your voice. Like you're on the verge of crying or something. "Hey, just wanted to call an say I can't make it tonight. One of my other girlfriends and I are gonna try being exclusive for a while and see how things work out. I'm sorry to do this to you, but this just happened today."
If you deliver it just right, you'll hear that tone in her voice that sounds of rejection and sorrow. Then, you call her right back a minute later. This time, you'll be screened to voice mail because she's crying and she doesn't want you to know it. This time, leave a voice mail and say "Hey, I just want you to know I think you're great. Seriously, you are an awesome girl. The only thing that didn't work out here was timing. Had I met you earlier, who knows what would have happened. Anyway, I just don't want you to feel bad about this. I really do think you are great."
At this point, you've got her feeling rejected. And that's a good thing because they only want what they can't have. And you've rejected her without being a dick. She realizes you're honest (even though you aren't).
I've done this successfully in the past one time, but there was no lying. After my exclusive relationship ended, I called her back 90 days later, fucked her once, went out with her again and lost interest. Oh well. It worked.
