Common wisdom that i don't follow:
Certain things that the PUA community at large accept to be true just seem to not mesh well with my personal experience. I'm not necessarily referring to THIS community, but the PUA community at large and especially the advice of some well-known PUA gurus.
I wanted to write this post for all the newbies out there who feel that some of my posts fly against page 46 of "The Game" or something else that they have read. I've read the same things. I want to put this out there for everyone, and I welcome new and experienced alike to comment on it and rip it apart as it relates to your own thoughts and/or experience. Nothing wrong with some good well-meaning disagreement.
I don't claim to have all the answers. I'm learning new things every day, and I mean that literally. So maybe I haven't looked at some of these things in the right way. Inasmuch as this is meant to teach, I also want to learn something. Anyway, away we go:
1.) Never introduce yourself (Mystery) - (thinking: it shows interest too early, it gives the girl too much value)
I do this all the time. Never once have i had it work against me in any way that I can remember. I've been blown out for other reasons, but never have i had a girl say "what? you told me your name?? well, i WAS in to you, mister, but clearly you don't have enough value for me!"
All it does is set the frame "WE ARE MEETING EACH OTHER NOW" and forces a small investment. Sometimes it helps, usually it has no effect either way.
2.) Never compliment a girl until she jumps through a hoop (Mystery) - (thinking: it is a chode thing to do. it raises her value relative to yours, it comes across as supplicating)
I use compliments all the time to great effect. Sometimes I open with compliments. Perfectly fine. Basically i use them to get a girl talking if she seems really shy or if it just feels like the right thing to do in the situation.
3.) Never use self-depricating humor (David DeAngelo) - (thinking: it lowers your value, and shows a lack of confidence)
Disagree. I use self-depricating humor ALL the time, it only serves to build rapport and it shows increased confidence.
4.) Use DHV-embedded stories to hit the attraction switches of "protector of loved ones, leader of men, and preselection" (Mystery) - (thinking: based on S&R theory, this is what girls are looking for. if you embed enough of these DHV's in to your stories, a girl will feel attraction. The maxim - Attraction is not a choice.)
In all honesty, a "told" DHV like this does create some attraction, the problem is that it is very weak and it does NOT get you nearly enough attraction to say, not get flaked on. Given the effort and time that you lose trying to do this, in my opinion this is a waste of 5 to 15 minutes. IMO not even worth adding to your game or worrying about. Let her discover your value for herself by being a strong, confident guy with a good sense of humor and a good heart. Try instead to have a two-sided conversation as early as possible. The goal should be to build investment more so than attraction. Or maybe rapport is the right word? Vibe and connect.
5.) 90/10 rule (Tyler Durden) - (thinking: girls are not going to carry the conversational burden of a conversation, so be prepared to do 90% of the talking for the first 5 to 15 minutes while she warms up)
True premise, bad advice. I ALWAYS strive to have the girl talk as much and as early as possible!!!! the danger is that you do NOT, i repeat NOT want to "put on a show" for her, and that was always the problem i had with this. You would talk, get no investment from her, and when you were done talking and the energy dipped, they would basically walk away. while you may end up doing 90% of the talking anyway, let it happen naturally. strive for 50/50.
6.) Never buy a girl a drink (Mystery) - (thinking: it lowers your relative value.)
I've done this wrong a couple times. The point is to not make it a supplication, but you have to balance it off with not being an awkward guy with issues. Personally I think buying girls drinks is cheesy and try to avoid it. I'm Swedish, and in my culture it is thought of as very cheesy and almost insulting to buy a girl a drink, even on a date. However, in the USA it's a part of normal culture. If she asks for a drink, simply make her jump thru a hoop first, then reward her with one. When i'm on a date i ALWAYS assume i'm paying for drinks, unless she seems weird about it.
7.) Neg or tease your target, especially the 10's (Mystery) - (thinking: a "10" believes her value is higher than yours, so you need to knock her down to your level in order to talk to her)
99% of the time i see this done wrong. There is NO DIFFERENCE between a 10 and a 7 in my experience. I can count on my fingers the number of times I've seen guys in this community get blown out for not negging/teasing enough (therefore having lower relative value a la Mystery). I have seen literally hundreds of guys blown out, and I've done it myself, for teasing where the girl just wasn't receptive to it. You do the math.
It's almost like some guys are doing it because they're afraid of being boring or chumpy.
8.) Never open your target (Mystery) - (thinking: it disarms the obstacles)
Here's my experience. You know what happens when you open the obstacle? The obstacle stays and talks to you, and the target wanders off. Unless it's a 2 set. In that case, what happens is if you're running a good set, the obstacle starts to like you, and the target just stands around. Just open the fucking target direct. If the obstacle tries to pull her away, either a.) ignore her and continue to engage your target or b.) set the frame with something to the obstacle "hey, we like each other are you cool with that?" c.) get a better wing man lol
9.) Always play hard to get, or be the challenging "prize" (Swingcat, others) - (thinking: we want what we can't have)
Yes, but for christ's sake do it right. 99% of the time i see it done wrong. Let me give my take on this. People want what they can't have, AS LONG AS THEY BELIEVE THEY CAN HAVE IT.
People seem to go WAY out of their way to prize themselves, when IMO it's completely not necessary and a waste of time. IMO the trick is just knowing what NOT to do. Don't be needy, sulky, whiney, etc etc etc and just have enough social calibration to know when to push and when to lay back. Just be a cool guy. Lest the girl should think that you're unattainable and then talk herself out of seeing you again.
10.) The belief that all women cheat, or all hot girls have a guy on the side (Tyler Durden) - (thinking: academic books like the red queen, sperm wars, some TD post)
I would say something mean here, but... Seriously if anyone believes this, STOP READING RIGHT NOW, go outside, and get some real life girl friends from planet Earth. Don't believe shit from some college professor dweeb whose wife left him for the pool boy so in a fit of rage and delusion and a need to make sense of his life decides to write some gay book. Some girls do, most girls don't. In the real world. If they will cheat on you with someone more 'alpha', they're more likely to just dump your ass for him.
11.) ALL Girls deep down appreciate a player (Mystery) - (thinking: girls love sex as much as men, they just don't want to feel like a slut. Therefore most girls will be OK with no-strings sex or FB relationships)
Doesn't match my experience. Some girls just want sex, but most want more. At least the majority of the girls I go for don't just want sex. If you want to sleep with a lot of girls, sometimes you are going to have to hurt their feelings. That's just the sad fact of life as it is in the real world of Peter Grimm. Some girls are just looking to get laid, (most of those are just looking for validation of some kind more than pure sex) but most girls we game day-to-day are looking for emotional assets. When you break them, she will cry, even if it isn't in front of you. Yes women love sex as much as men. But to deny that it affects them emotionally is just fantasy world stuff in my experience.
However, I will concede that my style of going for a lot of rapport and investment might play in to this. In some ways, I think the guys with a "lighter" game (which is most guys) are more humane in that way, but that's just theory.
OK that's all i can think of for now. I'm sure there are more.